HRWiki:Open Discussions

From Homestar Runner Wiki

(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
(→Specific Page Discussion and Naming: I've received a strong opposing argument)
(looked through every discussion, none have been active for a decade. important/unresolved ones already listed in relevant categories. being bold and archiving this)
 
(includes 28 intermediate revisions)
Line 4: Line 4:
== Policy ==
== Policy ==
-
{| border=1 cellspacing=0 cellpadding=4 style="border-collapse:collapse; width: 100%"
+
{| class="wikitable"
-
|-bgcolor=#eeeeee
+
! Topic !! Topic Description !! Discussion
! Topic !! Topic Description !! Discussion
|-
|-
Line 17: Line 16:
|
|
*Whether or not to allow users to have [[HRWiki talk:User space#Sandboxes?|"personal sandboxes"]]
*Whether or not to allow users to have [[HRWiki talk:User space#Sandboxes?|"personal sandboxes"]]
 +
|-
 +
| [[HRWiki:Manual of Style]]
 +
| HRWiki's policy on consistency with toon articles, etc.
 +
|
 +
*Whether or not to rename the page, and if so, what to.
 +
|-
 +
|[[HRWiki:Spoons]]
 +
|Warns members not to write about items as common and mundane as kitchen utensils.
 +
|
 +
*Whether this page [[HRWiki talk:Spoons#Is this page useful?|actually describes]] a useful guideline.
|}
|}
== Transcripts ==
== Transcripts ==
-
{| border=1 cellspacing=0 cellpadding=4 style="border-collapse:collapse; width: 100%"
+
{| class="wikitable"
-
|-bgcolor=#eeeeee
+
! Topic !! Topic Description !! Discussion
! Topic !! Topic Description !! Discussion
|-
|-
Line 31: Line 39:
== Specific Page Discussion and Naming ==
== Specific Page Discussion and Naming ==
-
{| border=1 cellspacing=0 cellpadding=4 style="border-collapse:collapse; width: 100%"
+
{| class="wikitable"
-
|-bgcolor=#eeeeee
+
! Page !! Page Description !! Discussion
! Page !! Page Description !! Discussion
-
|-
 
-
| [[Bubs's Keytar]]
 
-
| Describes the keytar Bubs used in [[cheatday]]
 
-
|
 
-
*Whether to [[Talk:Bubs's Keytar|include other keytars]], such as the one used in [[coloring]]
 
-
*If so, what its new name should be ([[Keytar]], which is currently a redirect, has been suggested)
 
|-
|-
| [[All Toons]]
| [[All Toons]]
Line 46: Line 47:
*Discussing if the [[Talk:All Toons#Rename|name should be changed]] to include everything listed, not just the toons.
*Discussing if the [[Talk:All Toons#Rename|name should be changed]] to include everything listed, not just the toons.
|-
|-
-
| [[KOT's VOQPCS!]]
+
| [[Bubs's Keytar]]
-
| An short which uses the name "The King of Town's Very Own Quite Popular Cartoon Show" in the opening, and "KOT'S VOQPCS!" in the menu.
+
| Describes the keytar Bubs used in [[cheatday]]
|
|
-
*Discussing [[Talk:KOT's VOQPCS!#Rename|which name]] the article should use.
+
*Whether to [[Talk:Bubs's Keytar|include other keytars]], such as the one used in [[coloring]]
 +
*If so, what its new name should be ([[Keytar]], which is currently a redirect, has been suggested)
|-
|-
| [[Hremails]]
| [[Hremails]]
Line 55: Line 57:
|
|
*Discussing if the [[Talk:Hremails#Name change: Hremails-Hremail|title]] should be changed to "Hremail".
*Discussing if the [[Talk:Hremails#Name change: Hremails-Hremail|title]] should be changed to "Hremail".
-
|-
 
-
| [[Hollerin' Jimmy's Hobby Kit]]
 
-
| Page about a recurring group of items, all released under the name "Hollerin' Jimmy".
 
-
|
 
-
*Discussion over whether it should be renamed just "Hollerin' Jimmy's", to account for all the items released under the brand better.
 
|-
|-
|[[In Search of the Yello Dello]]
|[[In Search of the Yello Dello]]
Line 66: Line 63:
*Whether to [[Talk:In Search of the Yello Dello#Moving.3F|move]] the pages to "In Search of the Yello Dello (New Version)", instead of "In Search of the Yello Dello New Version", etc.
*Whether to [[Talk:In Search of the Yello Dello#Moving.3F|move]] the pages to "In Search of the Yello Dello (New Version)", instead of "In Search of the Yello Dello New Version", etc.
|-
|-
-
| [[Template:SBCG4AP]]
+
| [[Strong Bad Smiling]]
-
| The navigation template for the SBCG4AP series of articles
+
| Traces the growing rate of appearances where Strong Bad smiles
 +
|
 +
*Who can update the [[Talk:Strong Bad Smiling#Statistics Table|Statistics Table]].
 +
|-
 +
| [[SBCG4AP Advertisement]]
 +
| Transcribes the first trailer for [[Strong Bad's Cool Game for Attractive People]]
 +
|
 +
*If the page should be moved to [[Talk:SBCG4AP Advertisement#3D Trailer|SBCG4AP 3D Trailer]] to match Telltale's video website.
 +
|-
 +
| [[MivaScript]]
 +
| An article about a rarely used scripting technology that [[The Brothers Chaps]] used when hosted on Yahoo!
 +
|
 +
*Whether the article is needed, and if not, where it would be appropriately merged.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Predictions]]
 +
| An article listing predictions made by characters about the future.
 +
|
 +
*Whether predictions made about future events [[Talk:Predictions|should be covered]] on [[History according to Strong Bad]] or on a separate article.
 +
|-
 +
| [[Made-Up Real Things]]
 +
| Lists various creations of characters that later began to exist in Free Country.
 +
|
 +
*[[Talk:Made-Up Real Things#is anyone thinking of new names|What name]] the page should now use
 +
|-
 +
| [[Hiatuses]]
 +
| Discusses periods of time where The Brothers Chaps have not updated the sites.
|
|
-
*Whether or not to [[Template talk:SBCG4AP#Huge|break up the template]]
+
*Whether the page should exist or not.
-
*How to go about breaking the template up
+
|}
|}
== Specific Page References and Wording ==
== Specific Page References and Wording ==
-
{| border=1 cellspacing=0 cellpadding=4 style="border-collapse:collapse; width: 100%"
+
{| class="wikitable"
-
|-bgcolor=#eeeeee
+
! Page !! Page Description !! Discussion
! Page !! Page Description !! Discussion
|-
|-
Line 82: Line 102:
|
|
*Whether [[Talk:Fourth Wall Breaks#Actually Fourth Wall Breaks?|watching H*R videos]] and talking to the viewers counts as breaking the fourth wall
*Whether [[Talk:Fourth Wall Breaks#Actually Fourth Wall Breaks?|watching H*R videos]] and talking to the viewers counts as breaking the fourth wall
-
|-
 
-
| [[Strong Bad Smiling]]
 
-
| Traces the growing rate of appearances where Strong Bad smiles
 
-
|
 
-
*Whether [[Talk:Strong Bad Smiling#Limits?|limits]] should be placed on the time frame covered in the article
 
|-
|-
| [[Strong Bad and Marzipan's Relationship]]
| [[Strong Bad and Marzipan's Relationship]]
Line 95: Line 110:
== Technical ==
== Technical ==
-
{| border=1 cellspacing=0 cellpadding=4 style="border-collapse:collapse; width: 100%"
+
{| class="wikitable"
-
|-bgcolor=#eeeeee
+
! Topic or Page !! Topic or Page Description !! Discussion
! Topic or Page !! Topic or Page Description !! Discussion
|-
|-
Line 103: Line 117:
|
|
*Who can create [[HRWiki talk:Spoons#Dynamic imagery|a template]] showing random pictures of spoons.
*Who can create [[HRWiki talk:Spoons#Dynamic imagery|a template]] showing random pictures of spoons.
-
|-
 
|}
|}
Line 109: Line 122:
*[[HRWiki:Projects#Unfinished and ongoing projects]]
*[[HRWiki:Projects#Unfinished and ongoing projects]]
-
[[Category:HRWiki Maintenance|{{PAGENAME}}]][[Category:Community Projects|{{PAGENAME}}]]
+
[[Category:HRWiki History|{{PAGENAME}}]]

Current revision as of 06:14, 1 October 2023

This page is experimental. If you have ideas on how it can be improved, please list them on the talk page.
Shortcut:
HRW:OD

These discussions are currently open and are in need of resolving, either by consensus or otherwise. If you're unsure how to list a discussion on this page, just do your best and someone will come along soon to help with the formatting.

Contents

[edit] Policy

Topic Topic Description Discussion
Character Relationships Pages on how characters relate to one another
HRWiki:User space HRWiki's policy on what is acceptable in the User namespace
HRWiki:Manual of Style HRWiki's policy on consistency with toon articles, etc.
  • Whether or not to rename the page, and if so, what to.
HRWiki:Spoons Warns members not to write about items as common and mundane as kitchen utensils.

[edit] Transcripts

Topic Topic Description Discussion
The Reddest Radish Dispute over what Strong Bad says

[edit] Specific Page Discussion and Naming

Page Page Description Discussion
All Toons List of all toons, games, main pages, etc. that have been put on the site.
Bubs's Keytar Describes the keytar Bubs used in cheatday
Hremails Gives information on toons in which Homestar hosts his own email show
  • Discussing if the title should be changed to "Hremail".
In Search of the Yello Dello A "Big 'Toon" available in three versions.
  • Whether to move the pages to "In Search of the Yello Dello (New Version)", instead of "In Search of the Yello Dello New Version", etc.
Strong Bad Smiling Traces the growing rate of appearances where Strong Bad smiles
SBCG4AP Advertisement Transcribes the first trailer for Strong Bad's Cool Game for Attractive People
MivaScript An article about a rarely used scripting technology that The Brothers Chaps used when hosted on Yahoo!
  • Whether the article is needed, and if not, where it would be appropriately merged.
Predictions An article listing predictions made by characters about the future.
Made-Up Real Things Lists various creations of characters that later began to exist in Free Country.
Hiatuses Discusses periods of time where The Brothers Chaps have not updated the sites.
  • Whether the page should exist or not.

[edit] Specific Page References and Wording

Page Page Description Discussion
Fourth Wall Breaks Catalogs characters' acknowledging that they are fictional characters within a created body of work
Strong Bad and Marzipan's Relationship Records the numerous moments of conflict (and peace) between Strong Bad and Marzipan

[edit] Technical

Topic or Page Topic or Page Description Discussion
HRWiki:Spoons Warns members not to write about items as common and mundane as kitchen utensils.
  • Who can create a template showing random pictures of spoons.

[edit] See Also

Retrieved from "http://www.hrwiki.org/wiki/HRWiki:Open_Discussions"