HRWiki:Open Discussions

From Homestar Runner Wiki

Revision as of 15:26, 14 June 2008 (edit) Wbwolf (Talk | contribs) (→Specific Page Discussion and Naming: It seems close to resolving, but should add Disco Tech) ← Older edit		Revision as of 15:37, 14 June 2008 (edit) (undo) Brightstar Shiner (Talk | contribs) (→Specific Page Discussion and Naming: "Whether if the page should kept"? And I thought Wolfy was confusing before... O_o) Newer edit →
Line 50:		Line 50:
	| Page about Bubs' college.		| Page about Bubs' college.
	|		|
-	*Whether if the [[Talk:Disco Tech|page should kept]].	+	*Whether the page is [[Talk:Disco Tech|notable enough]] to be kept.
	|}		|}

---

Revision as of 15:37, 14 June 2008

This page is experimental. If you have ideas on how it can be improved, please list them on the talk page.

These discussions are currently open and are in need of resolving, either by consensus or otherwise. If you're unsure how to list a discussion on this page, just do your best and someone will come along soon to help with the formatting.

Contents 1 Policy 2 Specific Page Discussion and Naming 3 Specific Page References and Wording 4 Technical 5 See Also

Policy

Topic	Topic Description	Discussion
Character Relationships	Pages on how characters relate to one another	What requirements a relationship needs to have to merit its own page

Specific Page Discussion and Naming

Page	Page Description	Discussion
Breaking into Strong Bad's House	Page about characters trespassing into each others' houses or into Bubs' Concession Stand.	Which name could cover all the known instances of breaking in.
Fake Sound Effects	Page about characters voicing sounds instead of an actual sound playing	Whether the page is noteworthy enough to warrant inclusion If kept, what its name should be
Full Screen Homestarrunner.com	Description of the Flash files and how to watch in full screen	Whether the page is useful enough to be kept If kept, what its name should be
Bubs's Keytar	Describes the keytar Bubs used in cheatday	Whether to include other keytars, such as the one used in coloring If so, what its new name should be (Keytar, which is currently a redirect, has been suggested)
Evolution of Characters	Page linking to various character evolutions	Discussing if the name needs to be changed. (Character Evolution, currently a redirect, has been suggested. See also the older talk page for previous arguments against the page.)
Disco Tech	Page about Bubs' college.	Whether the page is notable enough to be kept.

Specific Page References and Wording

Page	Page Description	Discussion
History according to Strong Bad	Catalogs Strong Bad's questionable recounting of the past	This page's scope and what counts as "history"
Fourth Wall Breaks	Catalogs characters' acknowledging that they are fictional characters within a created body of work	Whether watching H*R videos and talking to the viewers counts as breaking the fourth wall

Technical

Topic or Page	Topic or Page Description	Discussion
One-time User Reverts	When an anonny or a newly created user makes a single, constructive edit	If someone needs to revert their edit, what's the best way to let them know not to get discouraged; also concern that discouraged users may become vandals
Template:incomplete list	Notes articles that have sections that need expansion	Whether incomplete lists have no differences from Section Stubs
Deletion Summary Template	A template that tells when an article was put up for deletion and what the outcome was	Whether or not it's necessary

See Also

• HRWiki:Projects#Unfinished and ongoing projects