Talk:band names
From Homestar Runner Wiki
BazookaJoe (Talk | contribs) m (sectioning) |
Uglinessman (Talk | contribs) ("Misspelling method" examples) |
||
| Line 8: | Line 8: | ||
==Richie Kotzen== | ==Richie Kotzen== | ||
Whoever found the Richie Kotzen thing deserves a trophy, for serious. I always wondered if I'd misheard his name, and I guess that explains it. Thanks a ton! --[[User:TheNintenGenius|TheNintenGenius]] 01:14, 16 Jan 2005 (MST) | Whoever found the Richie Kotzen thing deserves a trophy, for serious. I always wondered if I'd misheard his name, and I guess that explains it. Thanks a ton! --[[User:TheNintenGenius|TheNintenGenius]] 01:14, 16 Jan 2005 (MST) | ||
| + | |||
| + | == "Misspelling method" examples == | ||
| + | |||
| + | In the section explaining about bands having names which are intentional misspellings of words and phrases, the example of [[Wikipedia:The Beatles|The Beatles]] was deleted, the rationale being ''"The Beatles" took their name as a play on the word "beat", not as a reference to the insect''. While it's true the word "beat" is the center of the pun, the pun is still there. It's not a "reference to" the insect specifically, but it's very obviously supposed to sound like the word "beetles", which makes it the most famous example of the type of band name being discussed. In fact, most of the band names offered as valid examples aren't specifically references to the thing being spelled incorrectly, it's the misspelling that's half the point. Def Leppard isn't a band devoted to songs about large cats, Aerosmith don't intend to teach people about the art of arrow making, and the remaining members of Led Zepplin don't likely care if their name brings to mind images of vintage blimps. If you insist on removing it again, the only rationale should be that the other examples given are of bands that are, or were considered at one time to be, metal, and it's obvious that the subject at hand is metal bands, but as a band name, The Beatles are a perfect example. - [[User:Uglinessman|Ugliness Man]] 18:25, 14 May 2006 (UTC) | ||
Revision as of 18:25, 14 May 2006
Advertisement
Hey guys at homestar runner.com I am in a christian heavy metal band and am trying to find a different name for my band. The current name Sinful Regret just dosen't feel very metal. Ya know so please help me find a new name
Signed Lost and confussed
- I can sympathize, but this doesn't belong on the Wiki. Feel free to create a user account and talk about your band on your user page, or make a post in the Off-Subject Discussion area of our forum, but Wiki discussion pages should only contain discussion about the Wiki. — InterruptorJones[[]] 11:15, 23 Nov 2004 (MST)
Richie Kotzen
Whoever found the Richie Kotzen thing deserves a trophy, for serious. I always wondered if I'd misheard his name, and I guess that explains it. Thanks a ton! --TheNintenGenius 01:14, 16 Jan 2005 (MST)
"Misspelling method" examples
In the section explaining about bands having names which are intentional misspellings of words and phrases, the example of The Beatles was deleted, the rationale being "The Beatles" took their name as a play on the word "beat", not as a reference to the insect. While it's true the word "beat" is the center of the pun, the pun is still there. It's not a "reference to" the insect specifically, but it's very obviously supposed to sound like the word "beetles", which makes it the most famous example of the type of band name being discussed. In fact, most of the band names offered as valid examples aren't specifically references to the thing being spelled incorrectly, it's the misspelling that's half the point. Def Leppard isn't a band devoted to songs about large cats, Aerosmith don't intend to teach people about the art of arrow making, and the remaining members of Led Zepplin don't likely care if their name brings to mind images of vintage blimps. If you insist on removing it again, the only rationale should be that the other examples given are of bands that are, or were considered at one time to be, metal, and it's obvious that the subject at hand is metal bands, but as a band name, The Beatles are a perfect example. - Ugliness Man 18:25, 14 May 2006 (UTC)
