Talk:Rankin/Bass
From Homestar Runner Wiki
(Difference between revisions)
Bad Bad Guy (Talk | contribs) (→Enough references?: Re-read the article and remembered I suggested one of those references myself.) |
(I think the significance warrants keep status here, even without the DVD commentary reference) |
||
| Line 7: | Line 7: | ||
::::Oh, and I vote for '''keep''' as well, since there's three references now and one of the main characters actually dressed up as one of the Rankin/Bass characters. [[User:Jennifer|Jennifer]] 03:23, 30 December 2010 (UTC) | ::::Oh, and I vote for '''keep''' as well, since there's three references now and one of the main characters actually dressed up as one of the Rankin/Bass characters. [[User:Jennifer|Jennifer]] 03:23, 30 December 2010 (UTC) | ||
:::::I think the issue of whether DVD commentary counts really needs to be addressed at some point; it feels really silly when we have [[Harry Potter|a page]] with three DVD commentary references and a T-shirt. As for someone dressing as a Rankin/Bass character, that alone does not count as criteria for including a page, lest we make one for everything that someone has worn costumes for (and with eleven to twelve characters per year and eleven Halloween toons (counting [[Which Ween Costumes?]]), that's quite a few!) --{{User:Jay/sig}} 05:00, 30 December 2010 (UTC) | :::::I think the issue of whether DVD commentary counts really needs to be addressed at some point; it feels really silly when we have [[Harry Potter|a page]] with three DVD commentary references and a T-shirt. As for someone dressing as a Rankin/Bass character, that alone does not count as criteria for including a page, lest we make one for everything that someone has worn costumes for (and with eleven to twelve characters per year and eleven Halloween toons (counting [[Which Ween Costumes?]]), that's quite a few!) --{{User:Jay/sig}} 05:00, 30 December 2010 (UTC) | ||
| + | ::::::I agree that not every character costume should get a page, but in this case though, [[Strong Mad]] and [[The King of Town]] were both dressed up as Rankin/Bass characters (I mistakenly only said one in my last comment), and there is a toon within a toon modeled directly after a Rankin/Bass cartoon (and I can't think of another time that's happened, so it's significant). So, there are three references (albeit two are in one cartoon) even without the DVD commentary (which I do personally feel should count in references, for reasons I said [[Talk:Harry Potter|here]]). I personally think that's significant enough to count as a running gag. [[User:Jennifer|Jennifer]] 11:33, 30 December 2010 (UTC) | ||
Revision as of 11:33, 30 December 2010
Enough references?
Usually, we require references in three toons for a page like this. Thoughts? Possibility of a third that I and the person who made the page both overlooked? --Jay (Gobble) 19:05, 27 December 2010 (UTC)
- There's a reference in the commentary for modeling. cash money tc 19:08, 27 December 2010 (UTC)
- I don't really see a reference to Rankin/Bass in the commentary of modeling.. all I really see is a reference to the song "Winter Wonderland", despite what the Fun Fact says. In this case, though, the two references might be interesting enough. Leaning toward keep.
OptimisticFool 19:12, 27 December 2010 (UTC)
- The reference in modeling is when Matt says Parson is a clergyman, and Mike says "I would assume so. He married Frosty". It's a reference to Frosty's Winter Wonderland where the children try to get a preacher named Parson Brown to marry Frosty and his snow wife. Jennifer 03:16, 30 December 2010 (UTC)
- Oh, and I vote for keep as well, since there's three references now and one of the main characters actually dressed up as one of the Rankin/Bass characters. Jennifer 03:23, 30 December 2010 (UTC)
- I think the issue of whether DVD commentary counts really needs to be addressed at some point; it feels really silly when we have a page with three DVD commentary references and a T-shirt. As for someone dressing as a Rankin/Bass character, that alone does not count as criteria for including a page, lest we make one for everything that someone has worn costumes for (and with eleven to twelve characters per year and eleven Halloween toons (counting Which Ween Costumes?), that's quite a few!) --Jay (Gobble) 05:00, 30 December 2010 (UTC)
- I agree that not every character costume should get a page, but in this case though, Strong Mad and The King of Town were both dressed up as Rankin/Bass characters (I mistakenly only said one in my last comment), and there is a toon within a toon modeled directly after a Rankin/Bass cartoon (and I can't think of another time that's happened, so it's significant). So, there are three references (albeit two are in one cartoon) even without the DVD commentary (which I do personally feel should count in references, for reasons I said here). I personally think that's significant enough to count as a running gag. Jennifer 11:33, 30 December 2010 (UTC)
- I think the issue of whether DVD commentary counts really needs to be addressed at some point; it feels really silly when we have a page with three DVD commentary references and a T-shirt. As for someone dressing as a Rankin/Bass character, that alone does not count as criteria for including a page, lest we make one for everything that someone has worn costumes for (and with eleven to twelve characters per year and eleven Halloween toons (counting Which Ween Costumes?), that's quite a few!) --Jay (Gobble) 05:00, 30 December 2010 (UTC)
- Oh, and I vote for keep as well, since there's three references now and one of the main characters actually dressed up as one of the Rankin/Bass characters. Jennifer 03:23, 30 December 2010 (UTC)
- The reference in modeling is when Matt says Parson is a clergyman, and Mike says "I would assume so. He married Frosty". It's a reference to Frosty's Winter Wonderland where the children try to get a preacher named Parson Brown to marry Frosty and his snow wife. Jennifer 03:16, 30 December 2010 (UTC)
- I don't really see a reference to Rankin/Bass in the commentary of modeling.. all I really see is a reference to the song "Winter Wonderland", despite what the Fun Fact says. In this case, though, the two references might be interesting enough. Leaning toward keep.
