Talk:Monkey Island

From Homestar Runner Wiki

(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
(Are these all really needed?)
(Reply)
Line 1: Line 1:
I'm noticing a pattern with these Telltale-related articles such as Monkey Island, Graham Annable, and Wallace and Gromit. There is, at most, one reference on the actual site, and then the rest being made up of references in Poker Night, Behind the Bad, PAX, etc.. Being a fan of all these series, I certainly like the idea of them having articles here, but it seems like all the references aren't so much references from the Chaps, but rather nods from Telltale to their other games. I mean, do we really need a new article for each time Telltale references another game of theirs? Could these perhaps be merged into one article? {{User:The Wheelchair/sig}} 16:58, 20 January 2011 (UTC)
I'm noticing a pattern with these Telltale-related articles such as Monkey Island, Graham Annable, and Wallace and Gromit. There is, at most, one reference on the actual site, and then the rest being made up of references in Poker Night, Behind the Bad, PAX, etc.. Being a fan of all these series, I certainly like the idea of them having articles here, but it seems like all the references aren't so much references from the Chaps, but rather nods from Telltale to their other games. I mean, do we really need a new article for each time Telltale references another game of theirs? Could these perhaps be merged into one article? {{User:The Wheelchair/sig}} 16:58, 20 January 2011 (UTC)
 +
:Especially the "appears in the game" references that don't really involve Strong Bad. We're not considering Poker Night at the Inventory part of the [[Homestar Runner (body of work)|body of work]], are we? We don't even have articles for any of the non-H*R main characters.  I think when there's only one in-universe reference, all the other stuff can be mentioned where that one reference would be mentioned normally; in this case, [[pet show]] and/or [[Floppy Disk Container]].--{{User:Johnny Jupiter/sig}} 17:20, 20 January 2011 (UTC)

Revision as of 17:20, 20 January 2011

I'm noticing a pattern with these Telltale-related articles such as Monkey Island, Graham Annable, and Wallace and Gromit. There is, at most, one reference on the actual site, and then the rest being made up of references in Poker Night, Behind the Bad, PAX, etc.. Being a fan of all these series, I certainly like the idea of them having articles here, but it seems like all the references aren't so much references from the Chaps, but rather nods from Telltale to their other games. I mean, do we really need a new article for each time Telltale references another game of theirs? Could these perhaps be merged into one article? The Wheelchair 16:58, 20 January 2011 (UTC)

Especially the "appears in the game" references that don't really involve Strong Bad. We're not considering Poker Night at the Inventory part of the body of work, are we? We don't even have articles for any of the non-H*R main characters. I think when there's only one in-universe reference, all the other stuff can be mentioned where that one reference would be mentioned normally; in this case, pet show and/or Floppy Disk Container.--.Johnny Jupiter! talk cont 17:20, 20 January 2011 (UTC)
Personal tools