Homestar Runner Wiki Forum

I'm not so sure on who to vote for. Capt. is a level-headed guy, but there's something nagging me that some of those votes weren't coincidence. And I think all of his votes have ended up in townspeople, but to be fair, they had enough "evidence" for them and they were kind of bandwagon. And Biscuithead looks supicious, but then again, I was dead-set than Ian was a wolf.

I'm abstaining until I can take a good look at this again.

And the serial killer is obviously inactive...maybe take a look at inactive users?

_________________

I still believe that Biscuithead is a villain and I vote for him.

_________________

I'm with Noid, I'm gonna wait until there's more a bit more information. I'll look through and try to find some stuff tomorrow.

Hey all, why are you voting for Biscuit? It'd be very enlightening for all of us to see why people are flocking to him. I know reasons might have been said before, but I would very much like to hear them again. I know what you mean, Noid, this is all suspicious. This is a lot tougher without the obvious story clues ^^;; Also, most people are either posting nothing or posting consistently, and those are difficult to read...

_________________

Ah, dang, I forgot all about this game...

I really have no idea who to vote for. I really don't have the brainpower or the strategic thinking for this kind of stuff.

_________________
So, so you think you can tell Heaven from Hell, blue skies from pain. Can you tell a green field from a cold steel rail? A smile from a veil? Do you think you can tell?

_________________

We really gotta look for evidence, guys - 3 rounds in and we're getting the crap kicked out of us. We can't let this be the first wolf win.

_________________

I'm going to have to abstain on this one, for lack of a better reason, or suspicion of a probable villain.

_________________

Ok guys, I went back and looked through the thread. I am now suspicious of Mike being the SK because of what I found.

So we know the SK missed the first killing period and then missed this last one as well. He/she only killed during the second night round. Whoes only been active during round two? Mike.

He only has two post outside of the mayor vote. They are as follows:





Both are during the time in which the SK killed. As well both posts point to Biscuit. That with the fact that Ian was human leads me to believe that Biscuit is not a mutant and that Mike is the SK. This is way to suspicious for my tastes.

I vote Mike.

_________________

Hmm...that sounds pretty good. Like Mike wanted to elect himself into power to avoid suspicions...

_________________

Hmmmmmmmm. Susan makes a pretty good point. Mike'd be a good bet in my opinion. So... I'll bet Mike.

_________________
So, so you think you can tell Heaven from Hell, blue skies from pain. Can you tell a green field from a cold steel rail? A smile from a veil? Do you think you can tell?

But Susan makes a pretty good point too. Mike has been ignoring the game, and so has the serial killer.

I think I will vote for Mike, since once again I have to bandwagon to save myself.

_________________
SIBHoD.

Hm, well at this point, I could point fingers at anyone to be a villain, or even the serial killer.
Make my vote abstain.

_________________

Biscuithead: 2 (JAU, BTG)
MikeMcG: 3 (Susan, Einoo, Biscuithead)
abstaining: 3 (Noid, Abu, Word Up)
Dang that's a lot of activity for 2 hours.

_________________

I vote Biscuithead, because he still seems very suspicious, and although Mike may be the SK, he can kill whoever he likes, so why would he be so eager to vote Biscuithead but never kill him himself?

_________________
Guten tag, Johann, du riechst ganz richtig. Danke schon, Heidi. Und du auch. - A Bit of Fry and Laurie

Delicious Biscuithead.

_________________

I'm thinking Mike right now.

_________________

mike seems right now

_________________

Susan, one question. How can you think Biscuit is a human purely because Mike voted for him. I agree with you that Mike is a huge candidate for the SK because of his inactivity, but we can't assume he's only going after townies. The SK is incredibly tough to read as his motives are going to be different than that of a mutant's.

Also, I don't think the SK knows what role everyone is. He probably can't differentiate between townie and mutant. That being said, someone he tries to kill in a day round could still be either; he wouldn't care either way, he wants everyone dead.

Mike seems to be a good candidate for SK, like you said. But I suggest we think hard on who to vote on later. The mutants are really beating us right now; we can't afford to overlook anything.

_________________

I was actually think about that just now. I realized that mike possibly being the SK does not prove biscuit is not a mutant at all. Imma go edit my other post.

_________________

Mike!

_________________
Will be on and off the forum for a while!

Mike what?

_________________
Guten tag, Johann, du riechst ganz richtig. Danke schon, Heidi. Und du auch. - A Bit of Fry and Laurie

Hmmm yes, I shall also vote Mike.


Susan brings up a great point.

_________________

I currently wish to abstain.

_________________

Biscuithead: 4 (Sean'd, JAU, BTG, lahi)
MikeMcG: 7 (Susan, Einoo, Biscuit, Abu, sbemail, Dacheet, Shadowfox)
Abstainig: 3 (Noid, Word Up, Potates)

_________________

That makes sense, but I am convinced that Biscuit is not a wolf. He's just too suspicious, and we all know what we thought of STu in the last game. Plus, everything I thought I knew turned out to be wrong.

I'm switching to MikeMcG.

_________________

I've got a strange feeling the villians are targeting Mike.

_________________
Click this link unless you hate Homestar Runner & Strong Bad. You like Homestar & Strong Bad, don't you?

If I were a villain I'd target Biscuithead.

_________________

Susan makes a good point, and Mike could easily be the SK, but I've gotta agree with SEAN'd here. Besides, the SK hasn't really been harming us all that much, I think getting the wolves now is more important than getting the SK.

So, Biscuithead

Maybe he's trying to throw suspicion off himself. If I were the serial killer and Ian died due to the SK before he was lynched, I would have looked suspicious, wouldn't I?

_________________